Camden College of Arts and Science Department of Philosophy and Religion |
Religion
332: Antisemitism and the Holocaust
Fall 2002
http://crab.rutgers.edu/~scharme/syllabus332.html
Professor Stuart Charmé
Office: 463 Armitage
Office hours: Tuesday/Thursday
3-4
Phone: 856-225-6237
e-mail: scharme@crab.rutgers.edu
Course
news and updates
Course
requirements
Course
schedule and Assignments
Antisemitism
and Holocaust Websites
|
Welcome to the class! This website contains all the assignments and all the handouts for the course. Make sure you print out your own copies of any readings, study questions, or other material and bring them to class when they are being discussed. For Thursday, December 5: NO CLASS DUE TO SNOW FOR Tuesday, December 10---Last Day of Class FINAL JOURNALS DUE! Read Unit #17
Please send a final e-mail to your group describing the most important thing you learned from the course. 3rd Quiz-- Study questions for quiz, click here |
| Student Webpages:
Christian Theology and the Holocaust--Kyle Theories of Racism and Antisemitism--Kira and Chris Anti-Semitism in Nazi Propaganda, 1933-1945--Kristen and Stephanie Leaders of the SS--Frank THE CATHOLIC CHURCH AND THE HOLOCAUST--Emily and Elise JEWISH RESISTANCE TO THE HOLOCAUST--Erika Righteous Gentiles--Elaine and Elyn Liberation
of Holocaust Survivors--Marisa
The Holocaust and Other Genocides--Katie Anti-Semitism
and Racism on the Internet --Andrea and Justin
Jews and Art:The Art of Persecution--Amy Holocaust
Denial--Lauren and Joe
|
| IMPORTANT: This web syllabus will change regularly during the semester. It is your responsibility to check for any changes to assignments between each class. Last updated: 12/5/02 |
This course offers an opportunity to examine the roots of antisemitism in western civilization and the path leading to the ultimate antisemitic outburst, the genocidal program of the Nazis now known as the Holocaust. We will try to understand how and why the holocaust happened, and to analyze the behavior of the victims, the executioners, and the survivors. We will then examine the implications of the holocaust for modern religion, for theories of human nature, and for situations we confront today and in the future. The course draws on material from history, psychology, ethics, theology, and literature in order to evaluate the possible responses to the Holocaust.
1. Reading assignments and class participation. The success of this course will depend on the degree to which the instructor and the students exchange ideas, share reactions to issues and events, raise questions, and develop sensitivity to the experiences of the people involved in the holocaust. It is crucial that each student keeps up with the reading in order to participate in the discussion both in class in his/her computer discussion group (See #3). For most of the readings there are study questions provided to help you focus on the most important issues in the readings. You should use these study questions while you are reading. Questions on quizzes will be drawn directly from these questions.
Regular attendance is also important for the success of the class. More than 4 absences during the semester will lower your grade. (5-8 absences = -1/2 grade; 9+ = -1 full grade or more)
2. Journal/Readings
annotations-- Each student must keep a personal journal separate
from his/her normal class notes. In the journal you will note
1) the
title of each reading assignment you complete
2) the
date you completed it
3) your
own annotations to either the readings or any material discussed in class.
Annotations are your concise reactions to the material you are reading,
a kind of capsule
review. Journals will be handed in once a month.
Your journal may be either hand-
written or word processed.
3. E-mail discussion group -- After the first class, I will subscribe you to one of three e-mail discussion groups. There are no rules for this discussion other than that it be intelligent, respectful, and somehow related to the topic of the course. You will be expected to make at least one contribution per week. Participation is included in your final grade.
Group 1 (last names from
A to G)
Group 2 (last names from
H to O)
Group 3 (last names from
P to Z)
4. Resource
guide on a selected topic.
You will prepared an annotated
guide to materials one of these topics or any other approved
topic. If more than one student wants to work on a topic, you
can work together.
Your resource guide should include a) an introduction that discusses the most important issues or questions and b) an annotated references in these categories: 1) Books; 2) Articles; 3) Websites; 4) Films or other materials. The resource guide should be in the form of a webpage that you can publish. Sample website
For help on publishing a web page at Rutgers, click here.
If you want to publish your
web page with a different internet provider, you can do so, but you'll
have to figure out how to
do so yourself.
Topics: Antisemitism
and the Bible
Christian Antisemitism
Antisemitism in France before the Nazis
19th Century German Antisemitism
Theories of Racism and Antisemitism
Hitler's Ideas about Race and Jews
Jewish Resistance to the Holocaust
Righteous Gentiles
The Holocaust and Christian Theology
American Policy toward Jews and the Holocaust
Antisemitism in the U.S. History
Antisemitism and Racism on the Internet
The Catholic Church and the Holocaust
The Phenomenon of Holocaust Denial
Antisemitism in the African-American Community
Relationship of the Holocaust to other modern Genocides
Neo-Nazis groups in the United States
Muslim
Antisemitism
After preparing your resource guide, you should be prepared to talk about your topic in class for 5 minutes or so.
5. Short Essays -- There will be several short essay assignments. Instructions to follow.
6. Quizzes -- There will be approximately 4 quizzes. Quiz questions will be drawn primarily from the Study Questions you have received.
If for any reason you need to miss class on the day a quiz is given, you must do the following in order to make-up the quiz.
a. Notify me (by phone
or e-mail) prior to class explaining why you need to miss the quiz.
b. Schedule a time
to make-up the quiz before the next class.
You will not be able to make up the quiz if you do not do these two things. Simply not showing up on a quiz day and asking to make it up later is not sufficient. No make-up quizzes are given after I have returned graded quizzes to the class.
7. Films -- There may be several films that you will be assigned to rent and watch on your own or watch on campus, depending on scheduling possibilities.
8. Trip
to Holocaust Museum in Washington, DC -- On
Sunday, November 3, there will be a class trip to the U.S. Holocaust Memorial
Museum in Washington. The cost for the trip [bus, museum admission,
etc.] will be approximately $20. This is a required trip.
Please make necessary arrangements to be available this day.
The trip will leave Camden at 8 am and return around 8 pm.
Instructions for your report on the museum
BOOKS:
Rubenstein and Roth, Approaches
to Auschwitz: The Holocaust and its Legacy
If you do not yet have a book (I think
the bookstore is out), I recommend you try this website to locate other
copies.
Click here.
Spiegelman, Maus I, II
Wiesenthal, The Sunflower
Wiesel, Night
On-line readings: On
the schedule below, you will find links to additional articles. For
most these you will be asked to enter your Rutgers computer account username
and password to access the readings. Whether or not you use
this account for e-mail, you must at least open the account so that you
have a Rutgers username and password. If you do not yet have
a Rutgers computer account, you can set it up by going to: https://clam.rutgers.edu/cgi-bin/rats.cgi
IMPORTANT:
When you access on-line readings, please remember
that you must type "your-username@clam" to be recognized by the Rutgers
system. If you leave off @clam it won't work. [Don't include
"rutgers.edu"]
| TOPIC | ASSIGNMENT | |
| 1 | General Issues and Questions | Rubenstein and Roth, "Prologue," 3-20 (Study Questions) |
| 2 | Greco-Roman and Christian Antisemitism | Rubenstein and Roth, "The
Jew as Outsider," 23-45 (Study
Questions)
"New Testament writings about Jews" |
| 3 | The Growth of Christian Antisemitism | Rubenstein and Roth, "The
Triumph of Christianity and the Teaching of Contempt," 46-65 (Study
Questions)
"Church Laws and Antisemitism" Martin Luther, "The Jews and Their Lies" [excerpt] Why Anti-Semitism?--An Evangelical View |
| 4 | From Emancipation to Dreyfus | Rubenstein and Roth, "The Irony of Emancipation: A French Connection" 66-89 (Study Questions) |
| 5 | The Development of German Antisemitism | Rubenstein and Roth, "Toward
Total Domination" 95-108 (Study
Questions)
German Antisemitism "The Jews in Hitler's Mental World" (Study Questions) Excerpt from Hitler's "Mein Kampf" |
| 6 | The Nazi treatment of the Jews-1933-1939 | Rubenstein and Roth, "Toward
Total Domination" -con't 108-125 (Study
Questions)
"Hitler's Rise to Power & the Legislative Attack on the Jews" Nurenberg Laws "What Would You Do?"-1930-1931 "What Would You Do?"-1936 "What Would You Do?"-1938 |
| 7 | World War and the Final Solution | Rubenstein and Roth, "War
and the Final Solution" 126-158 (Study
Questions)
"Eyewitness Account of Einsatzgruppen Execution "Testimony of a Survivor" |
| 8 | Victims and Survivors: Life in the Ghettoes | Spiegelman, Maus I, II
Rubenstein and Roth, "Victims and Survivors" 159-196 (Study Questions) The Warsaw Ghetto "What Would You Do?"-Ghettoes and Judenrat "What Would You Do?"-Partisans |
| 9 | Life in the Camps | The
Dilemma of Choice in the Deathcamps
An Episode at Auschwitz Night and Fog [script]-film Wiesel, Night
|
| 10 | The Question of Resistance |
Written assignment on MAUS, Night, Last Days dueJewish Resistance to Nazism: Its Various Forms and Aspects(and Study Questions) |
| 11 | The Portraits of the Perpetrators | What
would you do?-Einsatzgruppen
"Destroying the Innocent with a Clear Conscience" (+ study questions) |
| 12 | The Role of the Bystander:
Accomplice or Rescuer |
Rubenstein and Roth, "Business
as Usual" 229-253 (Study
Questions)
IBM and the Holocaust "The People of Le Chambon" "The Courage of a Polish Woman" "What Would You Do?"--Bystander |
| 13 | Responses of the Rest of the World to the Holocaust | "American
Attitudes About Jewish Refugees"
"The Abandonment of the Jews" |
| 14 | The Christian Churches Response to the Holocaust | Rubenstein and Roth,
"Their Brothers' Keepers?" 199-228 (Study
Questions)
"French Church Apologizes to Jews for Silence in Holocaust" "The Pope's in a Confessional and Jews are Listening" "We Remember: A Reflection on the Shoah" |
| 15 | The Issue of Moral Responsibility: Justice vs. Forgiveness | Wiesenthal, The Sunflower
Written assignment on the Sunflower- 500 words |
| 16 | Theological Implications of the Holocaust for Judaism and Christianity | Rubenstein and Roth, "The
Silence of God" 290-336 (Study
Questions)
"Religious Responses of Jewish Holocaust Survivors" |
| 17 | Implications of the Holocaust for Modern Society | Rubenstein and Roth, "The
Legacy of the Holocaust" 339-364
"Universal Declaration of Human Rights" |
| 18 | Muslim Antisemitism and other contemporary forms | Saudi Arabian Anti-Semitism |
9/5 Write an entry (250-300 words) for the "Oxford Encyclopedia of Ethnic and Religious Stereotypes" on the topic "Jew." Use as many examples as you can of stereotypes you have personally heard or know of. Go to the Internet and look for examples of stereotypes of Jews. (use keywords like antisemitism, KKK, Aryan Nation, White Power, White Supremacists, Kike, ZOG) Try to find actual examples not just descriptions by outsiders.
9/10 FOR Tueday, September 10: Read the Prologue of Approaches to Auschwitz and the first part of Chapter 1, up to p. 31. Make sure you look at the study questions.
FOR Thursday, September 12: Read Approaches to Auschwitz, Chapter 1 Make sure you look at the study questions.
FOR Tuesday, September 17: Review study question for Approaches to Auschwitz, Chapter 1. Read selections on Jews in the New Testament on syllabus. Read Chapter 2.
Please comment on the issue
of how the early Christian Church portrays Jews.
If you have not sent at
least one e-mail you are now behind.
FOR
Thursday, September 19: We will finish discussing the
issue of Christian Antisemitism. Read:
"Church
Laws and Antisemitism"
Martin
Luther, "The Jews and Their Lies" [excerpt]
Why
Anti-Semitism?--An Evangelical View
FOR Tuesday, September 24: QUIZ on Approaches to Auschwitz, Prologue, chapters 1-2. The quiz will consist of 5-6 questions drawn from the Study Questions you have. Your answers should be complete, concise paragraphs that answer the questions fully.
We will finish discussing
the issue of Christian Antisemitism. Read:
"Church
Laws and Antisemitism"
Martin
Luther, "The Jews and Their Lies" [excerpt]
For
Thursday, September 26: READ Rubenstein
and Roth, "The Irony of Emancipation: A French Connection" 66-89
JOURNALS
WILL BE COLLECTED ON TUESDAY, OCTOBER 1
For
Tuesday, October 1:
We will begin Unit 5. Read the following.
"Toward Total Domination" 95-108
German Antisemitism
"The Jews in Hitler's Mental World"
Tuesday, October 8:
We will finish Units 5 and 6. If you have not finished the readings in those sections, please do so.
I will collect money this week for the trip to Washington. Cost is $20. I will have a limited number of seats available for for friends and relatives on a first-come first-serve basis.
We will discuss possible topics for your research guides.
For Thursday Oct. 10th:
Review study questions for all readings in Units 4, 5, 6. Please discuss by e-mail any questions you have trouble with, and also bring your questions to class.
Please
sign up and pay for trip on Thursday, if you haven't already.
For Tuesday, October 15:
Please send an e-mail response regarding your answer to the "What Would You Do?" 1936, 1938
Start reading next chapter in Rubinstein and Roth book.
QUIZ
on units 4, 5, 6.
The
quiz questions will be chosen from among these questions:
How did the French Revolution affect the political, social and economic status of the Jews in Europe? [66]
How did the Enlightenment both contribute to the movement for emancipation of the Jews, but also to the development of racist antisemitism. [67-68]
Why did the Catholic Church oppose the emancipation of the Jews[69-70]
What
was the Dreyfus affair? [77-81] What was the significance of comparing
Dreyfus to Judas?
[79,
85]
What are "The Protocols of the Elders of Zion?" [82] What was the appeal of the theory of a secret Jewish conspiracy? [82-3]
What
was the appeal of Hitler to Germans in the late 1920s and early 1930s?
[100-101, 104]
What
were the steps by which Hitler gained political power in Germany? [102-104]
What
differences were there in the basic values of German Jews and German non-Jews?
(105)
According to Hitler, in what ways are "Jews" different from "Germans"?
What
connection does Hitler see between Marxism and the Jews? What other economic
images
of
the Jews does Hitler employ?
What kinds of religious language does Hitler use to describe his campaign against the Jews?
What
is the difference between rational and irrational antisemitism? What
are examples of each
kind
of antisemitism? What are the advantage and disadvantages of each?
[108-110]
What is meant by "paper violence"? How did the Nazis legislate antisemitism? 110-111]
What were the Nuremberg laws? What political and social consequences did they have? [113]
Why was forced emigration of Jews an unsuccessful policy? [120-123]
How
did the behavior of the rest of the world convince Hitler that the Jews
were in fact a
"surplus
people?" [124-125]
FOR Thursday, October 17, Read assignment in Unit 7 on the syllabus.
FOR
Tuesday, October 22, Read MAUS, vol. 1
FOR
Thursday, October 24, Read MAUS, vol. 2
For
Tuesday, October 29:
If you were not in class
on Thursday, you will need to rent the film we saw "Last Days" at a local
video store, since we will discuss it in class and you will also need to
have seen it for your next written assignment. Make sure you
send an e-mail response to the film before the next class.
Finish reading MAUS, if you haven't already done so. In addition, finish as much as you can of Rubenstein and Roth, "Victims and Survivors" 159-196
For Thursday, October 31:
We will have a short visit
from a Holocaust survivor.
Read Rubenstein and Roth,
"Victims and Survivors" 159-196
For Tuesday, November 5:
I will collect your journals today.
Send an e-mail response to Leon Kahn's dilemma in "What would you do?--Partisans"
Review study questions on chaper 6 in "Approaches to Auschwitz" and make notes of any that need clarification.
Read the first two selections in Unit 9, and begin Night if you can.
For
Thursday, November 7: Finish reading Night.
Report on Holocaust Museum
due
[Note new shorter length.]
For
Thursday, November 14: Read Unit #11, The Perpetrators
For
Tuesday, November 16: Unit #12 Bystanders
For
Thursday, November 21: Read Unit #14, "Christian Responses to the
Holocaust"
Thursday,
November 14: Essay on Maus, Last Days, Night due
Thursday,
November 21: Website workshop: Rough draft of research in
Word
file on disk should be done. 12:30 pm in the Library
basement computer lab.
Tuesday,
November 26 Your Website should be up and operational.
Please e-mail the website address to Professor Charme by this date.
For class, read:
Unit 14, "We
Remember: A Reflection on the Shoah"
Unit 16, "Religious
Responses of Jewish Holocaust Survivors"
For Tuesday, December 3: Read Unit #16
Brief
statements about their research from:
Kristen
and Stephanie, Marisa, Colleen